Wellness Wednesday: Committing To Your New Year’s Resolution Isn’t Enough
It’s New Year’s Day, and if you’re like most people, you’re probably thinking about your health and fitness resolutions for the year ahead. Maybe you’ve committed to working out more, eating healthier, or finally achieving a long-term goal that’s eluded you in the past. But before you dive in, here’s something important to consider: commitment alone isn’t enough to achieve lasting change.
How many times have you set a New Year’s resolution, only to find yourself falling back into old habits a few weeks later? Each January, we start strong, motivated by a clean slate and the desire for a better version of ourselves. But by February or March, the gym is less crowded, and those health goals seem a little harder to stick with. What if the problem isn’t your lack of discipline, but the way you’ve approached your goals?
This year, instead of just committing to a plan, let’s take a different approach—a deeper, more personal approach that can help you break the cycle and finally turn your resolutions into lasting habits.
Commitment vs. Deep Motivation: Why Surface-Level Promises Fall Short
It’s easy to commit to something on paper. Anyone can decide to start a workout routine or cut out junk food on New Year’s Day. But that surface-level commitment often isn’t enough to carry you through the challenges and setbacks that inevitably come your way. Why? Because it lacks emotional depth—it doesn’t mean enough.
Research published in The Journal of Behavioral Science shows that people who attach their goals to deeper, intrinsic motivations—such as improving health for the sake of loved ones, or achieving a greater sense of well-being—are far more likely to stick to those goals than those who are motivated by external factors like appearance or quick rewards.
This year, instead of focusing on surface-level goals like “lose 10 pounds” or “work out 5 days a week,” ask yourself: Why does this goal matter to me? Maybe it’s about having more energy to spend time with your family, reducing the risk of health issues, or simply feeling more confident and capable in your daily life. When your “why” is personal and meaningful, it acts as a source of motivation even when things get tough.
The Hidden Barrier: How Self-Sabotage Derails Progress
So if commitment isn’t the problem, what is? One of the biggest reasons people fall short of their goals is self-sabotage. Often, it’s not external obstacles that hold us back, but internal ones—like our own mindset. Two common mindsets that can sabotage success are perfectionism and all-or-nothing thinking.
Perfectionism: This mindset tells us that if we can’t do something perfectly, we might as well not do it at all. When we inevitably miss a workout or eat something outside of our plan, perfectionism convinces us that we’ve failed entirely, leading to guilt and frustration. Instead of bouncing back from a small slip-up, perfectionism makes us feel like we’ve lost the whole game.
Psychologists call this the “perfection trap.” Studies published in Cognitive Therapy and Research show that people with perfectionist tendencies are more likely to procrastinate, avoid tasks, and burn out when pursuing their goals. By demanding perfection, we set ourselves up for failure, because no one can maintain flawless execution all the time.
All-or-Nothing Thinking: This mindset tells us that if we can’t follow our plan exactly, there’s no point in continuing. For example, if you skip one workout, you might think, “I’ll just start fresh next week,” instead of picking up where you left off. This type of thinking turns small setbacks into full-blown derailments and prevents us from building consistency over time.
Psychologist Albert Ellis referred to this as "catastrophic thinking," where minor setbacks are blown out of proportion. In reality, progress isn’t about being perfect—it’s about showing up more often than not and being willing to get back on track after a misstep.
Breaking the Cycle: The Power of Finding Your "Why" and Shifting Your Mindset
To break free from this cycle of self-sabotage and finally turn your resolutions into lasting success, you need to take a different approach. Rather than relying solely on willpower or commitment, focus on finding your deeper motivation and shifting your mindset to embrace progress over perfection.
Find Your "Why": Dig deeper into why your goals matter. Instead of thinking, “I want to lose weight,” ask yourself what losing weight will allow you to do. Maybe it’s about feeling more energized, reducing health risks, or setting a positive example for your children. Connecting your goals to something meaningful will keep you motivated when the initial excitement wears off.
Shift Your Mindset: Challenge perfectionism and all-or-nothing thinking. Understand that setbacks are a normal part of the process. Missing a workout or indulging in an unhealthy meal doesn’t mean you’ve failed—it just means you’re human. Focus on consistency over perfection and remind yourself that progress, no matter how small, is still progress.
In fact, a study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people who practice self-compassion after making mistakes are more likely to stick to their long-term goals. Instead of beating yourself up for small slip-ups, acknowledge that they’re part of the journey and keep moving forward.
Reframe Your Resolutions: This year, instead of setting the same resolutions you’ve set before, reframe them with a deeper perspective. If your resolution is to “exercise more,” focus on how exercise will improve your overall well-being, energy levels, and long-term health. If you want to improve your diet, think about how better nutrition will help you feel more energized, reduce health risks, and enjoy life more fully.
The Key to Success in 2025: Personal, Meaningful Commitment
The reason so many New Year’s resolutions fail isn’t because of a lack of commitment—it’s because that commitment isn’t tied to something meaningful. When you connect your goals to your values, your identity, and the life you want to live, your motivation becomes more resilient. It’s no longer about sticking to a rigid plan; it’s about becoming the best version of yourself.
So as you enter this new year, remember: This year can be different. Not because you’ve committed harder, but because you’ve found a deeper “why” and have shifted your mindset to focus on progress, not perfection.
With this approach, you can finally break the cycle of failed resolutions and create lasting, positive change in your life. Here's to a year of growth, resilience, and becoming the best version of you! Happy New Year!
Partnering with a Health Coach for Success
One of the most effective ways to enhance your commitment and discover your deeper "why" is to work with a health coach. A health coach provides personalized guidance, support, and accountability, helping you navigate the challenges that arise on your journey. They can help you clarify your goals, uncover intrinsic motivations, and develop strategies to overcome self-sabotaging thoughts and behaviors.
This New Year, we invite you to take advantage of our exciting free trial offers! Join our Conquer Your Cravings Mindful Eating Program, where you’ll receive a comprehensive introduction to mindful eating and the tools you need to transform your relationship with food. This trial includes a free Personal Wellness Consultation with a Wellness Advisor, allowing you to discuss your unique goals and challenges in-depth. Together, you’ll create a tailored plan that resonates with your values and aspirations.
Additionally, our free Check Your DMs Program offers a supportive community where you can engage in discussions about mindful eating, personal growth, and wellness strategies. This trial not only connects you with like-minded individuals but also provides ongoing support to help keep you accountable.
With the right support and a fresh approach, you’ll increase your likelihood of sticking to your plan, finding your deeper motivations, and ultimately reaching your goals this year. Here’s to a year filled with growth, resilience, and the empowerment to become the best version of yourself. Happy New Year!
